Skip to content

Field note

Fixing a Running Toilet

A toilet that will not stop running wastes water all day. In most cases the fix is a cheap part and a few minutes of work.

  • Have ready: food dye
  • Have ready: replacement flapper
  • Have ready: adjustable wrench
  • Call us if anything looks worse than the guide describes
Call (365) 517-7959

Talk to a plumber now.
No forms, no waiting list.

  • Licensed & insured (details on request)
  • Phones answered 7 days a week
  • Oshawa & Durham Region
  • Upfront diagnosis before work
Steel open-end wrench lying on a wooden surface
One open-end wrench, the tool behind most tank-to-bowl repairs.

Why it matters here

Water and wastewater charges in Durham are based on metered use, so a running toilet adds to the bill. A badly leaking flapper can waste far more water in a day than the household drinks in a month. It also makes the fill valve work constantly, wearing it out sooner. The parts inside a tank are standard and easy to buy at any hardware store in town.

Step by step

  1. Lift off the lid. Rest it on a towel; tank lids break easily.
  2. Check the water level. If water is running down the overflow tube, the fill valve is adjusted too high or wearing out. Lower the float.
  3. Inspect the chain. A chain with no slack keeps the flapper from closing; too loose and it can get caught underneath.
  4. Do the dye test. Add a couple of drops of food dye to the tank water. Should colour show in the bowl within a quarter hour and nobody flushed, the flapper leaks.
  5. Replace the flapper. Shut the water, flush to empty the tank, unclip the worn flapper and fit a matching one.
  6. Replace the fill valve if needed. If it hisses, refills sluggishly or never stops running, a new one is a simple swap.

Bring the worn flapper along when you shop. They come in different sizes, and the wrong one will keep leaking.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Overtightening the plastic nuts under the tank, which can crack them.
  • Using bleach tablets that eat away rubber parts.
  • Ignoring a cracked overflow tube, which needs the whole flush valve replaced.
  • Bending the float arm on an old ballcock instead of adjusting it properly.

When to call a plumber

Phone if the toilet still runs after new parts, if the tank leaks onto the floor, or if the shut-off valve will not close. Older toilets are often worth replacing with an efficient new model through toilet installation. If you also want hotter showers, see electric water heater installation. For basement protection read backwater valves explained.

From our call log

Why does my toilet keep running for a few seconds by itself?

The flapper is leaking slowly into the bowl and the tank tops itself up. Replacing the flapper usually fixes it.

How a visit runs

  1. 1

    Call

    Describe the fixture, the floor and how old the building is.

  2. 2

    Look

    We pull the trap, the cleanout plug or the access panel before any price is given.

  3. 3

    Explain

    You hear what failed and what we would replace, in plain words.

  4. 4

    Fix

    Water off, old part out, new part in, joints supported.

  5. 5

    Test

    Full flow or full pressure, every joint checked dry.

Water on the floor right now?

Turn the main shut-off clockwise and ring (365) 517-7959.

Call (365) 517-7959
Call (365) 517-7959